Sometimes I Lie

Sometimes I Lie

Book - 2018
Average Rating:
Rate this:
Amber wakes up in a hospital. She can't move. She can't speak. She can't open her eyes. Though she can hear everyone around her, no one knows because she's in a coma. But she doesn't remember what happened. And she has a sneaking suspicion her husband had something to do with it. Alternating between her paralyzed present, the week before her accident, and a series of childhood diaries from twenty years ago, the narratives build and collide for an ending that leaves readers speechless. This novel delves into the blurred gap between who we are and who we'd like to be. Print run 200,000.
Publisher: New York :, Flatiron Books,, 2018.
Edition: First edition.
ISBN: 9781250144843
Branch Call Number: FICTION Feeney Alice 03/2018
Characteristics: 262 pages ;,24cm


From Library Staff

Obsessive Compulsive Disorder (OCD), child abuse, homicidal urges and the protagonist’s very unreliable memory will keep you guessing right up until the end.

The Wives read alike. Something bad has happened to Amber, she is paralyzed and in the hospital. She knows her husband did something, but what?

If you're waiting on "The Silent Patient" - this twisty novel also follows silent women who may have the truth locked inside them.

JCLKariE Jan 14, 2019

Tight plotting, fascinating characters and good writing make this psychological thriller fun to read. My brain was trying to unravel this mystery the whole time. I'm pleased to say the author shocked me with the ending.

JCLHeatherB Apr 24, 2018

I thought this was a decent enough mystery/thriller that was seriously marred by an overcomplicated and somewhat confusing series of twists at the end. Not terrible, but not essential reading, either.

From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment
Apr 16, 2021

Confusing but had a good payoff in the end. I would read more of her work.

Feb 07, 2021

Depressing, confusing, not a good read during covid times for sure.

Jan 31, 2021

Horrible book! I love a good thriller, but this was simply a depressing read with thoroughly unlikeable and depraved characters. When I realized that there could be no reasonable ending for this trainwreck of a story, I just prayed for the last page to come quickly.☹🥱

Jan 11, 2021

The story is confusing until about 3/4 s the way through, but the ending still has me confused. I didn't like the story's construction with the 3 different alternating time accounts - the childhood of the two girls, "then", and "now", but after reading the novel I see how that method worked for the author. Of the three accounts I was most interested in the "now" account which is where the suspense mounts. The two female characters are not attractive, personable, or likable. It was fortunate I didn't give up on the novel halfway through as the childhood diary entries, which I flipped through, didn't interest me. It's an odd story, but quite good if you stick with it. The title of the novel had me asking quite a few times as I read it - what are the characters lying about? Probably the novel with its 2 female characters and issues would be more of interest to female readers.

Dec 10, 2020

I read this book in a matter of hours. It had a great amount of twists and turns, and really held on to my attention. For a debut, I thought Feeney did an excellent job of spinning the characters' webs, jumping from different time perspectives, and throwing the reader through a loop when you thought you knew what was happening. I'd definitely recommend this book if you like a twisty thriller and a quick read.

Nov 06, 2020

Almost as good as Mo Haider, highly recommended. I also read "His and Hers", just as good if not better.

Oct 19, 2020

Wow, talk about a head-spinner! At the very beginning you are told the third thing about the protagonist is “sometimes I lie”. I went through the book assuming that some of the narrative was a lie. Then, as Amber reveals what you assume to be truth, you still have to question whether it is authentic.
I ended the book wondering which way the story was supposed to go.

Sep 12, 2020

I recommend that you read the book, then once you have fully absorbed the ending, go back and re-read it again. This is more like a psychological thriller. This is the 2nd book by this author that I have read, so I was prepared for twists and turns.

Aug 04, 2020

Thrilling original plot; cumbersome delivery. Slow start. Amazing finish!

No one can accuse Alex Feeny, author of SOMETIMES I LIE, of lacking imagination or being unoriginal. The plot is, conceptually, one twisty psychological mind bender, that isn't like anything I've read before. I would love to rate it 5 stars because to me, plot is the single most important factor in what makes a book a great reading experience. This has a 5 star plot that is unfortunately lacking some other key components.

The book is slow for the first 3/4. It feels repetitive, and it didn't really become a true page turning thriller until near the end. When it does start to gain momentum, there is a lot of confusion, as to who is speaking, and what is real and what is imagined by the main character.
She spends most of he story trapped in a coma, trying to make sense of her situation, wih fragmented memories about her past and what events led to her current predicament.

The plot is so clever, that i think in the hands of a more experienced and skillful writer, it could have been extraordinary. I'm not giving up on this author, though. Anybody with a mind that could come up with this plot has stories I don't want to miss.!

Jul 26, 2020

I love books that dole out the story little by little from different perspectives, and this book fills that bill. It's twisty, keeps the reader hooked, and pays off at the end. Good stuff!

View All Comments


Add Age Suitability
Jan 02, 2019

1percy1 thinks this title is suitable for 17 years and over

May 26, 2018

Mya614 thinks this title is suitable for 15 years and over


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at My Library

To Top